Tuesday, November 17, 2026Tue, Nov 17 Updated

Paris and France news in English, with the paperwork explained.

Whisper Halts Police Witness at Nanterre Murder Appeal Trial

A whispered prompt interrupted a police witness at the Nanterre appeal trial over Olivio Gomes's 2020 death. A verdict is due Wednesday.

Interior view of an American courthouse in Kirksville, Missouri, featuring a judge's desk and flags.
Photo: Zachary Caraway / Pexels

A whispered voice coached a police witness during his video testimony on Monday at the appeal trial of a former officer accused of killing Olivio Gomes, a father who was shot at the wheel of his car in the Paris suburbs in 2020. The cour d’assises des Hauts-de-Seine (the criminal court that hears murder cases) in Nanterre formally recorded the incident and ordered the video recording kept.

The advocate general, the prosecutor at the hearing, said he would report the episode to the competent prosecutor’s office and ask for an investigation into witness tampering and false testimony, according to actu.fr, which reported the hearing with AFP.

A voice from the witness’s side of the screen

The witness, identified as Harry S., led the plainclothes crew on the night of the shooting. He now works in the anti-crime brigade (BAC) in Saint-Denis de La Réunion and gave evidence by video link from his superior’s office there.

The presiding judge had paused to look through the case file for a diagram, ready to ask him where his colleague stood when he fired. At that moment a low voice came through from Harry S.’s end, telling him the officer should be placed on the right. Asked about it, Harry S. said he was alone in the office and that a colleague had tried to come in before seeing that a video hearing was under way. The judge had him turn his camera around the room, and no one else appeared. The court then considered whether he had been on the phone with someone during his testimony.

The judge said the court would draw every consequence for how much weight his testimony should carry. The advocate general said that in more than 300 trials before this kind of court he had never seen anything similar.

The shooting on Oct. 17, 2020

That night, Harry S. sat in the front passenger seat of a black, marked police Passat from the BAC. He decided to follow Gomes’s Clio after it overtook the police car, first on the Paris ring road (the périphérique) and then on the A13 motorway, as far as the foot of Gomes’s building in Poissy, in the Yvelines. Gomes was of Guinea-Bissau origin.

The accused officer, Gilles G., fired at Gomes three times. The second shot pierced both lungs and the thoracic aorta, and the 28-year-old died at the scene.

What the former officer told the court

The cour d’assises des Yvelines convicted Gilles G. of murder at his first trial and sentenced him to ten years in prison. He is appearing at the appeal free and no longer works in law enforcement. He maintains that he acted in self-defense.

Questioned in person on Monday, he said he had joined the police young and wanted to do well. He said he had ordered Gomes to cut the engine and stop the car, then saw the steering wheel turn toward him and fired at the same moment. He told the court he did not know why his brain told him to shoot.

He accepted that not all of his shots were useful or necessary to save his life. At the first trial he had already admitted that two of them, including the fatal second shot, were unnecessary. On Monday he went further: he said he had moved out of the car’s path, and that his shots were not what saved him or stopped the vehicle. He said he had not seen that way out before firing. “I did what I could,” he said.

What this means for the appeal

The whispering episode puts in doubt the account of the officer who chose to start the pursuit, a central witness on where Gilles G. stood when he fired. The court has already said it will weigh this when judging his testimony. Whether a separate criminal inquiry opens is now up to the prosecutor’s office that receives the advocate general’s report.

Verdict due Wednesday

The appeal court is expected to deliver its verdict on Wednesday.

Source: actu.fr