Attal, Retailleau, Lisnard Back Primary; Philippe Still Says No
Attal, Retailleau and Lisnard now back a primary to pick one centre-right candidate for 2027. Edouard Philippe still refuses to take part.

Three of the four figures asked by Senate president Gérard Larcher to settle on a single candidate for the 2027 presidential election now appear ready to hold a primary. Gabriel Attal, Bruno Retailleau and David Lisnard are favourable to the idea, according to franceinfo, while Edouard Philippe keeps repeating that he will not take part.
Their teams were due to meet on Tuesday, Nov. 17, to start working out how such a vote would be run.
Larcher’s call for one candidate
Larcher, who presides over the Sénat (the upper house of parliament), called on Saturday, Nov. 14, for a primary that would produce one candidate for the centre and the right in 2027. The question has been dividing that political bloc in recent days, franceinfo reported.
Philippe, the mayor of Le Havre, is now the only one of the four holding out. The other three have moved from hesitation to open support, and franceinfo describes the recent converts as the most active in pushing the process forward.
An empty chair at Tuesday’s meeting
The Tuesday meeting brings together the chiefs of staff of Attal, Retailleau and Lisnard. A seat has been set aside for Philippe’s team and left empty. Someone close to Attal told franceinfo that the empty chair was “not a joke”, which the broadcaster read as a way to keep pressure on Philippe. The other camps believe the process has to move ahead with or without him.
According to franceinfo, Retailleau and Attal, both described as badly weakened in the polls, want to discuss:
- the dates of the vote
- the debates between candidates
- the fee charged to voters, which they would likely keep as low as possible to bring in the largest number of participants
Who would be allowed to run
The hardest point is likely to be the scope of the primary, meaning which political families could take part. This could create tension with Lisnard. The mayor of Cannes, who franceinfo says is now ahead of his rivals, wants a very broad primary that does not rule out Eric Zemmour.
Lisnard’s camp believes it is negotiating from a position of strength. One of his supporters summed up the goal to franceinfo: the camp is fighting “macronisme” and wants to win the primary.
What it means for voters in France
A primary would let supporters of the centre and the right vote to choose one candidate for the 2027 presidential election. The rules now under discussion, including the fee to vote and the debates, set how open that vote would be to residents who want to take part.
Two questions remain unsettled. One is whether Philippe joins, since a primary without him would not produce the single candidate Larcher asked for. The other is whether the field extends as far as Zemmour, as Lisnard wants. Franceinfo did not report a date for the vote itself; the dates are among the points the teams began discussing on Nov. 17.
Source: franceinfo



