Train Ticket Row Ends in €148k Damages Bill for French Passenger
A dispute over a €50 SNCF fine turned into a criminal case and damages of €45,000 to the inspector and €103,000 to SNCF. Here is how it happened.

A 39-year-old man who refused to give his ID to an SNCF (France’s national rail operator) ticket inspector in 2021 has been ordered to pay €45,000 in damages to the inspector and €103,000 to SNCF. The Dijon Court of Appeal upheld the ruling in 2025, and the man, named only as Arnaud, told Le Parisien this week that he and his wife are divorcing and selling their home because of the bill.
SNCF says he was convicted of serious violence against its employee. Arnaud denies hitting the inspector but admits threatening him.
From a €50 fine to a criminal court
- April 2021: After his grandmother died during the Covid lockdown, Arnaud boarded a TGV from Aix-en-Provence to Paris for the funeral. Because his wife worked for SNCF, he had a family ticket that cost only the €2.60 reservation fee, valid if he showed his pass. He told Le Parisien he could not validate the pass at the station. The inspector moved to fine him, Arnaud refused to show ID, and police removed him from the train at the next stop.
- Soon after: the inspector was given five days of sick leave, later extended to 8 days, after a doctor found a slight injury to one finger.
- October 2021: Arnaud was convicted of insults, threats and violence causing an Incapacité Totale de Travail (a period of inability to work) to a transport employee. He was fined €500 and ordered to pay a symbolic €1 to SNCF and €850 in provisional damages to the inspector.
- 2024: Once the inspector’s condition had stabilized, which took 18 months, the court in Mâcon set civil damages at €45,000 for the inspector and €103,000 for SNCF.
- 2025: The Dijon Court of Appeal confirmed the judgment in full.
What the two sides say
SNCF says Arnaud assaulted the inspector. Arnaud rejects that and says he later offered to pay the fine, but was told the process had already started. He admitted to Le Parisien that he threatened the inspector with death “but without touching him,” adding that police pinned him to the ground.
The inspector became severely depressed after the incident, according to The Local France. His claim listed nearly €30,000 in lost bonuses, €15,000 for the finger injury, €2,500 for weight gain, €10,000 for having to give up boxing and €8,000 for loss of libido. SNCF calculated its own claim tied to his sick leave at €103,468.
SNCF told Le Parisien the amount was set after a court-ordered medical examination, that the sum has not been paid yet, and that Arnaud can contact its lawyer to arrange a payment plan.
What it means for train passengers
The standard fine for traveling without a valid ticket is €50. Passengers who think a fine is wrong are generally advised to pay it and contest it afterward, and those who could not show a pass during a check can get the money back by producing a valid pass later.
The case escalated once the refusal to give ID turned into a confrontation with the inspector. The fine itself became a criminal conviction, and the civil damages were decided separately, only after the victim’s condition had been assessed.
Source: The Local France



